Allergy shots, tablets or drops: which one fits your life?

Allergy shots vs. allergy drops:

A side-by-side comparison

Schedule Today
Feature
Allergy drops
Allergy shots
How it’s taken
Allergy drops
Liquid drops you place under your tongue at home, every day. Mixed from your own test results.
Allergy shots
Injections just under the skin of your upper arm, given in our office every time.
Effectiveness
Allergy drops
Months, not weeks, before you notice a change. The evidence for compounded drops is the weakest of the three routes, and the dosing is not standardized.
There is no reliable evidence that drops match shots, and we are not going to tell you they do.
Allergy shots
Months, not weeks, before you notice a change. Shots have the longest and largest body of evidence of the three routes.
Regulatory status in the U.S.
Allergy drops
Off-label. These are liquid drops mixed for you from extracts the FDA licensed for injection, not for use under your tongue. Off-label use is legal, but you should know that is what this is.
Allergy shots
FDA-licensed allergen extracts, given the way the license covers them, by injection. Not every allergen has a licensed extract.
Convenience
Allergy drops
Taken at home, so no weekly visits. Your first dose is supervised here in the office.
Allergy shots
Office visits once or twice a week during the build-up, then about every 2 to 4 weeks, with a 30-minute wait after every dose.
Safety
Allergy drops
Mouth itching and throat irritation are common. A whole-body allergic reaction, including anaphylaxis, is less likely than with shots but still possible, which is why the first dose is supervised here.
Allergy shots
A whole-body allergic reaction, including anaphylaxis, is uncommon but real. That is why you wait 30 minutes in our office after every shot and why we keep epinephrine at hand.
Cost & Insurance
Allergy drops
Almost never covered. Plans commonly describe sublingual immunotherapy other than the licensed tablets as investigational, so plan on paying out of pocket. We verify your benefits and tell you what you will owe before you start.
Allergy shots
Generally covered by most plans, but coverage is specific to your plan. Billing has two parts, the injection visits and preparing your extract, so you may see more than one charge. Because there are a lot of visits, your per-visit share is the number that matters most. Ask us to work it out with you first.
Commitment
Allergy drops
3 to 5 years of drops every single day. The usual way it fails is a bottle left in a drawer.
Allergy shots
3 to 5 years of office visits: once or twice a week at first, then about every 2 to 4 weeks.

So which one should you pick?

The right choice depends on your test results, how many things you react to, how far you live from us, and what your plan covers. What follows is a guide, not a recommendation. Immunotherapy is built from your own results, so testing comes first. Call (678) 689-1100 and we will tell you honestly which of the three your plan will pay for and which one you are likely to finish.

An amber dropper bottle on a stone surface surrounded by leaves

Choose allergy shots if…

  • You react to several different things at once, since shots can be mixed to your results.
  • You want the route with the longest track record and the largest body of evidence.
  • You need treatment your plan is likely to cover, and you can get to Lawrenceville or Watkinsville for the visits.
Schedule a consultation
An amber dropper bottle on a stone surface surrounded by leaves

Choose tablets or drops if…

  • Your problem is mainly grass, ragweed or dust mite. Ask about the FDA-licensed tablets first, since many plans cover them when their criteria are met.
  • You cannot do needles, or your child cannot, or you live too far away to finish a schedule of weekly office visits.
  • You react to several things and are willing to pay out of pocket, knowing that drops are used off-label in the United States.
Schedule a consultation

Nothing on this page is medical advice. Individual results vary. Whether a treatment is right for you is decided at an in-person evaluation.